Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecoLogic Auto 4dr Car Review - March 2012

REVIEW
List Price: £11,995
Tax Band: G
Insurance Group: 16
MPG: 41.5
CO2: 161
0-62 Mph: 14.3 secs
BHP: 110 BHP
Range: N/A miles
CarSite Verdict:  3/5
The Proton GEN-2 Persona ecoLogic Auto has adequate standard equipment. Its chassis is notable with an exterior that’s attractive enough. These two points are the main thrust of the Proton GEN-2 and nothing else. Depreciation is heavy and the driving experience on offer is not a particularly impressive one in terms of refinement. It does handles fairly well however, with sharp and responsive steering.

PROS:  The Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecoLogic Auto 4dr is a saloon that is more sophisticated than the hatchback version. The ecologic 1.6 engine runs on either petrol or LPG translating to savings on fuel costs. It’s very affordable.

CONS:  The interior is a big disappointment. The engine and gearbox are noisy. The engine is slow and does not offer an engaging drive.

Behind the Wheel

The 1.6 litre engine was developed for a model that can comfortably cruise at speed. This version is an automatic 4-speed gearbox saloon more popular to mature drivers. The ecologic or dual-fuel version engine runs on both petrol and LPG. Performance is generally ok but the engine is at its best at higher speeds.

Solid road grip is key to the ride of the Proton GEN-2, enabling it to take corners with ease and minimal body roll. However, though the steering is quick, it lacks the necessary weight and feel of rivals such as the Ford Focus. Refinement is not great and wind and road noise can be rather intrusive, particularly at speed.

The Proton GEN-2 is fitted with a 1597 cc engine with 4-cylinders and 16-valves. It reaches 62 mph in 14.3s and tops the speedometer at 115mph. The ecologic engine produces 110 bhp at 6000 rpm of power and 109 lb-ft at 4000 rpm.

Looks & Equipment

The dual-fuel model is not more expensive than the conventional version. The interior quality of the Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecoLogic Auto has improved but it is still not on par with its rivals. For the most part, it looks cheap because of the use of poor plastics. The dashboard is well-laid out but the buttons and knobs are quite fiddly. However the same buttons and knobs are easy to read and are quite functional.

The Proton GEN-2 saloon has a trim level with a respectable amount of equipment. It is fitted with air-conditioning, electric mirrors, electric front and rear windows, MP3/iPod connectivity, split/fold seats, a rear boot spoiler and front foglights. The automatic gearbox is a cost option. Other options are metallic paint and leather seats.

Practicality, Safety & Reliability

The Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecologic features a respectable level of practicality and safety equipment. The roofline is sloping and that gives this version limited headroom but there’s enough space in the front and rear seats. The boot has decent size and shape. It has 430 litres of storage with the seats up and around 860 litres with the seat down.

The Proton GEN-2 has a braking system composed of ABS and a string of electronic braking distribution which makes this version very stable when heavy breaking occurs. Missing though is stability control. The Proton GEN-2 saloon has quite a strong body shell with a petrol tank that has been positioned on the centre of the car’s shell to lessen the risk of damage. The usual air bags, Isofix and belt pre-tensioners are inclusive. Security kit such alarm, immobiliser, remote and central locking are also included. Deadlocks are not standard.

The overall build quality of this model is disappointing. The engine’s reliability still remains to be seen. The Proton GEN-2 is covered with a 3 year or 60,000 mile warranty and 3 years roadside assistance coverage.

Value for Money

Priced at £11,995, Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecologic surely undercuts many of its competitors. It has a combined mpg of 41.5 thanks to its dual-fuel system. Its CO2 emission rating is 161g/km, under insurance group 16 and Road Tax Band G which indicates fairly cheap running costs for the class.

The GEN-2 is certainly far from being a class leader but undoubtedly offers great value for money for what it is. However, depreciation is heavy so don't expect good resale values.

Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecoLogic Auto 4dr Car Review - by 
All Proton Gen-2 Reviews
Proton GEN-2 1.3 GLS 5dr - March 2012
If a car badge is not the first consideration you look for in a car, then the Proton GEN-2 should interest you. It is not powerful enough to top the medium family car category, but sound engineerin...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GLS 5dr - February 2012
The GEN-2 is the replacement for the old Wira, but even when it was first launched it felt and looked dated next to similar Kias or Hyundais. It does offer plenty of practical space in the boot and...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX 5dr - March 2012
The Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX 5 door is relatively good to drive thanks to its Lotus-developed chassis. However, the whole car feels dreadfully cheap and nasty and the noise from the engine at higher re...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX Auto 5dr - March 2012
The Proton GEN-2 is an affordable alternative to cars such as the VW Golf, Ford Focus, Vauxhall Astra and Skoda Octavia. The drive is acceptable and handling is decent but it is not particularly e...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX ecoLogic Auto 5dr - March 2008
Oh dear. Whilst Hyundai are Kia are raising the bar for cars from the Far East, Proton are still in the doldrums. The GEN-2 drives well thanks to a chassis developed by Lotus, but the rest of the c...
Comments
Medium Family Alternatives

You might want to read reviews for other Medium Family cars that you can then compare to the Proton Gen-2. Here are some popular Proton Gen-2 alternatives:

NEW RELEASE
Jeep Avenger revealed for 2023
NEW RELEASE
Ferrari Purosangue revealed
NEW RELEASE
Ford Mustang revealed for 2023
NEW RELEASE
New BMW M2 has been revealed
NEW RELEASE
Electric SUV coming soon
NEW RELEASE
Popular hatchback gets an update