Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona 4dr Car Review - February 2012

REVIEW
List Price: £11,195
Tax Band: G
Insurance Group: 7
MPG: 42.8
CO2: 157
0-62 Mph: 12.0 secs
BHP: 110 BHP
Range: 471 miles

CarSite Verdict:

 2.5/5

The Proton GEN-2, 1.6-litre Persona, four-door saloon looks more sophisticated than the hatchback version. Its boot is more secure than that of the hatchback but like the hatchback it’s a disappointing drive overall. There are many cars which are superior and not much more expensive and the low quality and dated looks of the GEN-2 make it difficult for it to compete with its rivals in this class.

PROS:  More sophisticated looking than the hatchback. Good level of equipment.

CONS:  Poor quality interior. Dull driving experience. Steep depreciation. Unrefined engine

Behind the Wheel Looks & Equipment Practicality, Safety & Reliability Value for Money

Behind the Wheel

For the price you pay you’d expect a bit more than the cloth upholstery and low quality plastic trim you find in the interior of the cabin. The overall finish is lacklustre and disappointing. Adjustment for finding your ideal driving position is decent and the front seats are comfortable and supportive. The dashboard design is practical even if all the controls aren’t as easy to use as the steering wheel mounted audio controls.

The 110bhp, 1.6-litre petrol engine produces 109lb-ft of torque and takes you from 0-62mph in 12 seconds and on to a top sped of 118mph, but getting there requires working the engine hard. Throttle response in low gears is disappointing and unresponsive. Its less than precise handling makes city driving tiring, but it's tolerable on a motorway cruise, despite the noisy engine. Road noise and wind noise although present are not intrusive.

The Proton GEN-2, 1.6-litre Persona offers little in the way of driving pleasure. The brakes feel sloppy and vague and the five-speed gearbox isn’t any better. The four-speed auto option is even worse - slow to respond and quite old-fashioned. The GEN-2 Persona's handling is competent even though it can feel vague when cornering and the steering doesn’t really provide much in the way of feedback for the driver.

Looks & Equipment

Similar to the hatchback, the Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona 4dr just looks dated – it has the look of a car a generation behind its rivals – both inside and out.

All Personas are reasonably well equipped with central locking, power steering, electric windows, electric door mirrors, 15-inch alloy wheels, air-conditioning, ABS, CD+MP3 connectivity, halogen headlamps, tinted glass, an alarm, an immobiliser and rear parking sensors as standard. Metallic paint and leather seats are also available as optional extras.

Practicality, Safety & Reliability

The boot in this saloon version is slightly less spacious than in the hatchback but it’s still large enough for most needs offering 430-litres with the rear seats in position and 860-litres with them folded down. It offers comfortable space with good head and leg room for adults. Although trying to get three adults in the back is a squeeze, three children should be quite comfortable.

Euro NCAP have not crashed tested the GEN-2 1.6 Persona 4dr yet. Its safety features include ABS, front and rear crumple zones, side-impact bars and rollover protection. The Persona only has two airbags - one for the driver and one for the front passenger - which is poor. An alarm, immobilizer and remote central locking are fitted as standard to deter against theft.

The build quality of the interior is poor and the cheap plastic trim does not look durable. However, Proton’s engines and mechanicals are tried and tested so you shouldn’t have much to worry about on that score. The GEN-2 Persona comes with Proton’s three-year, 60,000 mile warranty and regular service intervals of 9,000 miles.

Value for Money

For the £11,195 price tag you do get quite a large car for your money, but Protons do not hold their value well and there are rivals such as Mitsubushi’s Lancer or Chevrolet’s Lancetti that offer better value for money, certainly in terms of refinement and handling.

The Proton’s average fuel economy of 42.8mpg and CO2 emissions of 157g/km make it competitive in its class and offer reasonably economical motoring. Group 16 insurance and Road Tax in VED band G shouldn’t break the bank either.

A used GEN-2 with full service history may be your best bet: you’ll still get a lot of car – but for a lot less money.

Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona 4dr Car Review - by 

All Proton Gen-2 Reviews

Proton GEN-2 1.3 GLS 5dr - March 2012
If a car badge is not the first consideration you look for in a car, then the Proton GEN-2 should interest you. It is not powerful enough to top the medium family car category, but sound engineerin...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GLS 5dr - February 2012
The GEN-2 is the replacement for the old Wira, but even when it was first launched it felt and looked dated next to similar Kias or Hyundais. It does offer plenty of practical space in the boot and...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX 5dr - March 2012
The Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX 5 door is relatively good to drive thanks to its Lotus-developed chassis. However, the whole car feels dreadfully cheap and nasty and the noise from the engine at higher re...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX Auto 5dr - March 2012
The Proton GEN-2 is an affordable alternative to cars such as the VW Golf, Ford Focus, Vauxhall Astra and Skoda Octavia. The drive is acceptable and handling is decent but it is not particularly e...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX ecoLogic Auto 5dr - March 2008
Oh dear. Whilst Hyundai are Kia are raising the bar for cars from the Far East, Proton are still in the doldrums. The GEN-2 drives well thanks to a chassis developed by Lotus, but the rest of the c...

Alternatives

Medium Family

You might want to read reviews for other Medium Family cars that you can then compare to the Proton Gen-2. Here are some popular Proton Gen-2 alternatives:

Comments

Quick Search

Make
Model
Popular Searches: Audi, Ford, VW
Automotive News
CONCEPT
Volkswagen has revealed a 395bhp Golf which will hit 62mph in less than four seconds. Blimey!
NEW RELEASE
Volkswagen's updated Touareg features improved efficiency and a range of styling tweaks.
NEW RELEASE
Toyota has unveiled a new facelift of its Yaris supermini, which goes on sale in the UK this summer.
CONCEPT
Citroen's new C-XR concept, which previews a future production SUV, has gone on show in Beijing.
CONCEPT
Audi's new offroad concept hints at a new range of TT-branded cars.
NEW RELEASE
Porsche has fitted its new Macan SUV with the engine from the Golf GTI.

Proton Gen-2