Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecoLogic 4dr Car Review - March 2012

REVIEW
List Price: £11,195
Tax Band: G
Insurance Group: 7
MPG: 42.8
CO2: 157
0-62 Mph: 12.0 secs
BHP: 110 BHP
Range: 471 miles

CarSite Verdict:

 1/5

The Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecoLogic Auto is supposed to be an environmentally friendly model but only offers 41.5mpg. It's cheap, but it feels cheap and the quality of the interior is absolutely shocking. On the plus side, it can run on either petrol or LPG, however, when was the last time you saw a petrol station that sells LPG?

PROS:  The 1.6-litre engine is quick enough for most people's driving needs, and the ecoLogic can run on either LPG or petrol, potentially resulting in significantly lower fuel costs.

CONS:  Poor build quality, poor refinement, lack of interior space.

Behind the Wheel Looks & Equipment Practicality, Safety & Reliability Value for Money

Behind the Wheel

The GEN-2's 1.6-litre engine develops 110bhp at 6000rpm and 109lb-ft of torque. However, it is extremely coarse and noisy, especially at higher revs.

The ride is pretty decent and the handling is fairly good thanks to the Lotus-developed chassis. However, the Proton still can't match its European rivals for driving enjoyment. The GEN-2's refinement is absolutely shocking. In addition to the engine noise, wind and road noise are evident even at moderate speeds, making the cabin very uncomfortable indeed.

Looks & Equipment

The saloon Persona ecoLogic comes with its own unique trim level, different from that of the Hatchback body style. On top of the basic GLS trim including twin front airbags, air-conditioning, electric front windows and alloy wheels, the saloon is equipped with a rear boot spoiler, electric rear windows, front fog lamps and electric mirrors.

Although the cabin’s styling is neat and contemporary, it feels very cheap and the quality if the plastics is very low indeed. Many of the control feels weak and flimsy too, and will probably break if you're not careful with them.

Practicality, Safety & Reliability

There's plenty of legroom in both the front and rear, but the steeply sloping roofline compromises headroom. The boot has a decent size and shape, offering 430-litres with the rear seats up and 860-litres with the rear seats down.

The car comes with twin front airbags and anti-lock brakes but side airbags are unavailable which is pretty poor by modern standards.

The Proton doesn't feel very well built but it is offered with a 3 year/60,000 mile warranty as standard.

Value for Money

The GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecoLogic Auto 4dr is relatively well priced at £11,995 but resale values will be very poor indeed.

The 1.6 engine has average fuel consumption of 41.5mpg (combined) and the car falls under group 16 for insurance and road tax band category G. Running the car on LPG will save you money but if you really want to save cash, you're better off buying a hybrid or a vey economical diesel car.

Proton GEN-2 1.6 Persona ecoLogic 4dr Car Review - by 

All Proton Gen-2 Reviews

Proton GEN-2 1.3 GLS 5dr - March 2012
If a car badge is not the first consideration you look for in a car, then the Proton GEN-2 should interest you. It is not powerful enough to top the medium family car category, but sound engineerin...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GLS 5dr - February 2012
The GEN-2 is the replacement for the old Wira, but even when it was first launched it felt and looked dated next to similar Kias or Hyundais. It does offer plenty of practical space in the boot and...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX 5dr - March 2012
The Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX 5 door is relatively good to drive thanks to its Lotus-developed chassis. However, the whole car feels dreadfully cheap and nasty and the noise from the engine at higher re...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX Auto 5dr - March 2012
The Proton GEN-2 is an affordable alternative to cars such as the VW Golf, Ford Focus, Vauxhall Astra and Skoda Octavia. The drive is acceptable and handling is decent but it is not particularly e...
Proton GEN-2 1.6 GSX ecoLogic Auto 5dr - March 2008
Oh dear. Whilst Hyundai are Kia are raising the bar for cars from the Far East, Proton are still in the doldrums. The GEN-2 drives well thanks to a chassis developed by Lotus, but the rest of the c...

Alternatives

Medium Family

You might want to read reviews for other Medium Family cars that you can then compare to the Proton Gen-2. Here are some popular Proton Gen-2 alternatives:

Comments

Quick Search

Make
Model
Popular Searches: Audi, Ford, VW
Automotive News
MOTORING ISSUES
Over a quarter ok Brits who take motoring holidays in Europe do so without any extra vehicle prep.
NEW RELEASE
Two world-firsts in technology will make the Volvo XC90 a world leader in driver safety.
MOTORING ISSUES
Alliance of British Drivers say plans to introduce road pricing plans are unwelcome.
CAR TALK
The Fiesta becomes the UK’s best-selling vehicle ever, passing the 4,115,000 mark this month.
CAR TALK
Ssangyong announce 3-year free servicing package as part of a summer offer on its 4x4 range.
CAR TALK
Peugeot celebrate the launch of their new city car with a new app for phones/tablets.

Proton Gen-2